Shame

  • The New Year Effect

    The New Year Effect.

    Mental Health - New Years Resolutions

    Hello, and welcome back as we start the first month of this new year.

    Two things often happen with me at this juncture, and I wonder if they happen to you, too. One, the build-up to the holidays can be any combination of rushed/stressed/anxious/get-me-out-of-here/fun/when can I sit down/great to see everyone/cool gifts given and received…and everything in between. In short, it’s a lot.

    And two, the abrupt, sudden stop to the preparations – well, because the day finally arrived – sometimes left me feeling somewhat adrift and untethered in the days that followed – not sad, exactly, but with the New Year looming I always felt I had to get my act together, for real this year, because you know – hopes and dreams.

    I’d like to share a brief anecdote with you because I have been thinking about my own new year, and that made me think of you. (If you noticed I used the word “looming” –that is what it felt like, sort of like the Sunday Scaries and you’ve got a project due tomorrow you haven’t even started. Yuck.) I think I now understand why I, and maybe you, have mixed feelings about the calendar turning over: it’s a fresh start (good) that can induce pressure (not so good) to be better, do better – and don’t forget to add in the things we should stop doing.

    In my case, a particular context set the stage for these mixed feelings. In my family of origin, there was a certain tradition I never quite understood (and came to dislike). My father would put on a record (yup, an album) of Christmas carols, gorgeously sung by a highly professional German choir. Because the record was old, it had small scratches from the needle making its way around for at least a hundred Christmases, which became a familiar part of the experience. Ok, so far so good.

    But here’s the thing: within ten to fifteen seconds of the music starting, everyone was crying. Usually someone would make a forlorn remark about time going by so fast, but mainly you had to be silent, weeping. It seemed to me one of the very few times I saw my parents express what had to be deep, though wordless, emotions. But this annual event was stubbornly central to the evening – it was just what we did. Every year, the build up to Christmas included the anticipation of sobbing. Good times!

    I think for years, the Christmases of my youth, with their pathos and sorrow and the regrets and sadness swirling around the adults, had a dual effect of wearing me out and spurring me on not to be like them, not to dwell in regret and the past. The present couldn’t even get a seat at the table.

    So, we come to what I call The New Year Effect: the pressure (self-imposed or otherwise), the habit and the wish to kick of a new year with bold, marvelous, lofty, important goals – so that – here’s the kicker – we can become “better” than what we are today, and fix the regrets of yesterday. The New Year Effect can induce feelings of shame. (Click here to read all about how to tame shame.)

    Lest you start swearing at me or feel an urge to leave the site, I hasten to add that bold, marvelous, lofty goals are terrific. But, if we create them from a place of “I’m not good enough”, hoping and expecting that whatever transformation that occurs will make men or women flock to us, get us raises, help us lose twenty pounds and make us the thinnest person at that 25-year reunion in May (because then things will be great and I’ll finally feel really good about myself), we’ll be headed for trouble. Maybe you will get those things. But I have some doubts.

    Achieving goals that have even a teeny bit of people-pleasing attached to them, or are driven by any “should”, or are accompanied by the expectation that they will make us feel different, better, happier, more liked – are very unlikely to be deeply satisfying in the long haul. Deeply satisfying, along the lines of “I can’t wait to go back to my project, it’s so hard and fun” or “It feels so good to be making new friends. I needed this.”

    The typical way many of us think about New Year’s resolutions is inherently problematic: we tend to focus on what we need to stop doing (things we like) and start doing (things we don’t really like). It’s no wonder that by February those resolutions have weakened or disappeared altogether – and we feel worse about ourselves for it.

    Let’s think about this new year differently. Let’s think about our hopes and dreams for the year and create them from a place of love and acceptance about who we are today. We are perfectly imperfect the way we are. And let’s give ourselves permission to stop working towards that goal if it no longer seems to fit or excite us.

    Wanting to achieve anything – more fitness or health, more close friendships, starting a business, writing a book, repairing a relationship, learning a new skill – all need our most positive, excited self as the launching pad. Shame and its favorite partner guilt will sabotage our beautiful goals come February 1, when we may feel we’ve bitten off more than we can chew, or the steps to that goal start to feel overwhelming. Shame (which is not the core of you, it’s the carried part from the past) will find an opening to inflame self-doubt. And that’s a terribly deflating way to embark on your new year.

    How about instead, come February 1, you lasso any discouragement or self-doubt, let it sit there, then spend some time reflecting about whether your goal just needs modifying, or a different timeline? Or perhaps you could get some help with it? Or, have you changed your mind and something else feels more important now, that you hadn’t thought of before? See Quitting is for Winners for some thoughts on the beauty of letting go of things.

    My goal last year was to launch Thriving Bravely in July. Now I find that comically hysterical! It was lofty all right, but so unrealistic because I didn’t know at the time how much longer each step would take than I had planned. So, I fine-tuned how I was working, kept going, blew through a few deadlines, met others, and here we are. I loved every minute of it, and had I launched in July it wouldn’t be what it is today. It needed time and so did I.

    Would you like some ideas about how to make your new year dreams come true? I thought so : )

    Creating a solid foundation for success

    • Find your “why”. Keep asking yourself “why is this important to me?” until you feel you’ve reached the core desire. Here’s a common example: “I want to lose 20 pounds.” Why? “I’d like to feel healthier and have my clothes fit better.” Why? “I’ll feel more confident.” Why? “Because it will help me feel stronger.” Why? “It will decrease my depression and build my self-esteem.” You get the idea. In this case, sounds like feeling less depressed and better about yourself is actually the goal; losing 20 pounds is one of the strategies.

    • Get very clear on how achieving your resolution will improve your life, and be aware of any thoughts that surface about how you hope others will feel about your achievement. This is your year, not theirs.

    • I love huge goals, but smaller ones are fantastic too, because they feel immediately rewarding and keep our energy up. For example: “This year I am determined to say something kind to myself, everyday. I’ll write it down.”

    • At Thriving Bravely we look for small moments of joy. Could one goal be to slow down and notice the little things that inspire happiness, wonder, love? (I got a darling white lilac bulb in a tiny vase, and watching it blossom makes me smile every time I walk past it.)

    • Revisit what you set out to do, often. Examine its ongoing importance to you, tweak your schedule to fit it in, or abandon it and choose something else if your interest has changed (that too is growth).

    • Watch out for resolutions like “I’m not going to eat Cadbury’s mini-eggs this year.” If you feel less candy would be a good resolution, how about “I’m going to enjoy my Cadbury’s as a treat on the weekend.”

    • Resolutions are destined for the garbage heap if they feel like deprivation or an endurance test. They are made to be enriching, not to spoil fun!

    Here are some of my intentions this year: continue being my wholehearted self, laugh more at my quirks and flaws, and love my peeps and my animals as much as I possibly can.

    Best wishes to you for the New Year.

  • Taming Shame

    Taming Shame

    Shame is an extraordinarily loaded feeling and reaction. I’ll bet it’s at the top of most peoples’ lists of feelings they loathe. It’s a close cousin to guilt, which I will explain.

    We are not born feeling shame; it is an internal response to humiliation, judgment, and rejection by people we care about and love. Shame is a searing moment when terrible things are said or done to us, and standing there, red-faced, we wish more than anything that we could be swallowed up by the ground under our feet.  Shame is when we feel wholly inadequate as a person, exposed, broken, even – and worthy of the rejection itself.

    Shame is someone else dumping their pain on us.

    Guilt, on the other hand, is a feeling we get when we have crossed a moral boundary of our own (or society’s). For example, if you took money off your parent’s dresser when you were young, you probably felt guilty. Anticipating guilt, from doing something we are thinking about, but know is wrong, can help us put the brakes on and thus steer clear of engaging in that behavior. For sure, guilt can occur when someone tells us we’ve hurt their feelings. So we apologize, own our transgression and move on.

    However, if we have not addressed the core feelings that live inside us, from being shamed growing up, the shame can easily attach itself to instances where we feel guilt, making that normally transient emotion larger-than-life, all-consuming and leaving us feeling worthless and about one inch tall. If that. So, shame and guilt can be toxic companions.

    Can the beast of shame be tamed? Yes! I can’t promise total eradication, because we can’t erase our early experiences of shame – but we can explore them, try our best to understand them, and work to recognize that feeling shame is not our fault and was not caused by us. Try to imagine an infant experiencing shame. Exactly.

    So, to summarize: incidents of humiliation (or coercion and abuse) by a parent or other person whom we love, care for and depend on, create shameful feelings that lead to (a usually unconscious) belief that indeed, we are insufficient and deserving of devaluation. We often perpetuate the shame by judging ourselves harshly. This pattern can manifest in choosing relationships that mimic the behavior of the original shamer, not trusting our own feelings (further invalidation), and living with excruciating self-doubt and self-sabotage.

    We’ve seen how shame and guilt can be cozy partners. Add depression and anxiety to that duo and we can end up in a full-blown crisis. I know, it sounds like taming shame is harder than you thought and it would be understandable if you are now wondering if the toxic mess shame generates can be stopped (or at least wrangled into submission). Yes, it can. And I am going to show you how.

    I’ve purposely detailed my thoughts on shame to underscore how imperative it is that we get a handle on it. Tackling the problems of depression and anxiety are going to, at some point, unearth hidden (or maybe not so hidden) pockets of shame. That’s ok. More than ok. It’s a good thing. Because sunshine is the best disinfectant.

    Ready to move on to some ways to bring shame out of the darkness, and give it the heave-ho? Let’s go.

    EMPATHY

    Empathy is the mother of all shame antidotes. Shame doesn’t stand a chance against it.  Empathy towards ourselves and others is the pathway to belonging and connection, which in turn become the way we heal. (Read anything by Brené Brown, PhD, MSW to go deeper into your understanding of shame).

    • Show yourself some love. Spend some time, every day, feeling into a few things you love about yourself. There is just one you in the world, here to share your gifts and be the truest you possible. Here, I’ll go first. I love myself for my generosity with time, love and money. I love that I am resourceful and good at solving problems. I love my auburn, curly hair (finally! I was teased endlessly for it in middle school and back then wished I had pin-straight blonde). I love myself for my kind heart. Now you try. It’s not bragging. It’s owning who you are. It’s ok to not like some things about ourselves – as long as shame isn’t the driver and you work to frame it as perfectly acceptable to be imperfect. (I am working on this too.) The artist Salvador Dali wrote: “Have no fear of perfection – you’ll never reach it.” We’d do well to absorb this message of acceptance.

    • Consider asking your partner or a close friend to tell you three things they love and admire about you. (Notice if your inner voice says “Really? They’re just being nice”; that’s a big molecule of shame trying to bust the party.)

    • Find some mantras that work for you, write them down and say them, feel them, believe them. I know, this sounds a little woo woo, but stay with me here. It helps in challenging that old shame voice, coaxing it to into submission. A few of my go-to mantras are “When I stay connected to the core me, I am unstoppable” and “I love myself and therefore have more love to give”. Google self-love mantras and see what resonates.

    • Who in your life has offered you empathy? What was it about their presence, words and behavior that felt empathic to you? (One of the most enduring memories I have of being shown empathy was my amazing 4th Grade teacher Mrs. Stokes. I was riddled with anxiety and she saw it, gently embraced it, and soothed it with kind words, praise and patience.)

    • How do you manifest empathy towards others? Who are these lucky people? What things trigger your empathic response? (By the way, the activation of our empathy towards others can offer interesting information about our own shame; we sometimes recognize in others what we needed but did not get).

    TELL YOUR STORY. EXPLORE YOUR NARRATIVE OF SHAME. Shame feeds on secrecy and all variations of self-doubt such as “what will she think of me if I reveal how I feel?” Stuck in our heads and hearts, shame calls the shots – but, when we call it out by speaking about it, shame loses its grip. You can start by asking yourself some questions, such as:

    • Who shamed me when I was young? What did they say or do (to me)?

    • How do I remember reacting at that time?

    • Who else in my family carries shame? How do I know this? Perhaps they are people-pleasing, overly solicitous, angry, unkind, narcissistic, lonely, depressed, entitled, very uncomfortable with feelings (tend to leave the room if a feeling is even mentioned), quick to judge others about appearance, their tastes – or anything at all?

    • What do I know about family members’ histories? (Shame is often transferred through generations.)

    These can be painful questions, leading to painful answers. No need to go it alone. I highly recommend engaging in therapy while exploring them, which will provide you with a safe relationship and additional perspective, especially if your shame is connected to trauma. (Perhaps the course A Thriving Life might be right for you; in it we do a deep dive into shame.) Click here to learn more

    We need to accept ourselves as we are,
    before we can become who we want to be.

    You’ve got this.